ArtListings > News > Archive > Louvre accused of 'overcleaning' Leonardo masterpiece

Louvre accused of 'overcleaning' Leonardo masterpiece

31 December '11 by the editors | Source:

Art historians at the Louvre have been accused of "overcleaning" a masterpiece by Leonardo da Vinci, leaving the painting with a brightness that was never intended.

Two of France's top art experts have registered their displeasure at the cleaning of The Virgin and Child with Saint Anne by stepping down from their posts at the Paris museum's advisory committee responsible for its restoration, according to reports.

The resignations of Ségolène Bergeon Langle and Jean-Pierre Cuzin – former specialists in conservation and painting respectively – will be seen as a major embarrassment for the Louvre, as well as to their former colleagues on the committee.

The committee's 20 members include two specialists from the National Gallery in London, Larry Keith and Luke Syson.

Bergeon Langle is regarded as France's national authority on the art and the science of restoring paintings. She was director of conservation for all of France's national museums.

She said: "I can confirm that I have resigned from the international consultative committee, but my reasons I am reserving for a meeting with the president-director of the Louvre, Henri Loyrette."

The restoration has divided the committee between those who believe the painting is now too bright and those who regard the cleaning as moderate, The Guardian reported.

A Louvre source said that Mr Keith and Mr Syson were particularly keen on the restoration 500-year-old painting saying: "The English were very pushing, saying they know Leonardo is extremely delicate but 'we can move without any danger to the work'.

“There was a row a year ago about solvents because they said they were safe and Bergeon Langle said they're not safe. It took a long time before the committee really had explanations on the chemicals used on the picture. Details were asked for [by the critics on the committee], but didn't come for months …

"There are people who are very much for bright hues and strong cleaning. Those people are in charge."

Seventeen years ago, the Louvre abandoned an earlier attempt to clean the painting amid fears about how the solvents were affecting the sfumato, the Renaissance master’s trademark effect for blurring contours. Since then, it appears that the British influence on restoration has helped to sway the Louvre.

Read entire article...

More news

Exclusively for guests of Art Rotterdam, we now present Hotel Rotterdam. During Art Rotterdam, Hotel Rotterdam offers overnight stays in the studios and homes of artists in Rotterdam.
27 December '11

The Association of International Photography Art Dealers will hold the 32nd edition of The AIPAD Photography Show New York, one of the world’s most important annual photography events, March 29 – April 1, 2012, at the Park Avenue Armory in New York City.
27 December '11

Masterworks of the traditional fine arts of Japan will be on view during New York’s Asia Week in JADA 2012: An Exhibition by the Japanese Art Dealers Association.
26 December '11

From New Year, dealers and auctioneers must pay artists' heirs up to 4% of the sale price of works sold for more than €1,000.
26 December '11

Art by Damien Hirst and Andy Warhol outperformed the Standard & Poor’s 500 index over the past 10 years, according to a new measure by Artnet AG designed to rank the performance of art as an asset.
25 December '11

The Metropolitan Museum of Art announced that it is collaborating with Google to allow users to search the Web via pictures they take on their mobile phones, to increase access to information online about its encyclopedic collections.
22 December '11

The VIP Art Fair has announced the list of exhibitors for its second edition, which opens in February.
20 December '11

A four-day New York auction of the belongings of Hollywood star Elizabeth Taylor has fetched more than $150m, with one leather-bound film script selling for 50 times its estimate.
18 December '11

Street artist Banksy has installed a vandalised sculpture of a priest in a gallery in Liverpool.
16 December '11

In mid-December Foam presents the first major retrospective exhibition in the Netherlands of the work of Joel Sternfeld (1944, New York), one of the pioneers of color photography.
16 December '11

The Museo del Prado is presenting to the public for the first time The Wine of Saint Martin’s Day by Pieter Bruegel the Elder, the leading figure within 16th-century Flemish painting.
14 December '11

A painting believed to be by the street artist Banksy has appeared in Liverpool city centre.
14 December '11

The extraordinary beauty, rarity and provenance of the pearl known as “La Peregrina” inspired a fierce bidding battle at Christie’s New York at the opening auction of The Collection of Elizabeth Taylor.
14 December '11

The most expensive Chinese work of art at auction is still not paid for, more than a year after it was bid to 51.6 million pounds ($83 million).
13 December '11

Monet's Waterloo Bridge, created during one of his stays at The Savoy, is returning to the London hotel over 100 years after it was drawn.
13 December '11

Major auction houses and galleries have been caught up in Beltracchi’s fake art scam
12 December '11

In an effort to grow its business, a Melbourne hotel is displaying an original work by street artist Banksy - and inviting people to walk off with it. For the next month, starting on December 15, any guest who successfully manages to steal “No Ball Games” - a painting valued at up to $15,000 - will be allowed to keep it.
12 December '11

Celebrated German artist reflects on his work before opening of his biggest UK show, at White Cube gallery in London.
12 December '11

Follow ArtListings
New on ArtListings
Latest art news