Ansel Adams Trust Files Suit Over $200 Million Negative Scam

25 August '10 by the editors

SAN FRANCISCO – The controversy over Rick Norsigian's trove of alleged Ansel Adams negatives has reached a fever pitch, with the Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust filing a lawsuit to stop the sale of merchandise made from the glass plates — and asserting in the process that the Fresno artist is, in fact, a scam artist.

According to the Associated Press, the Trust is suing for "trademark infringement, false advertising, trademark dilution, and unfair competition," among other crimes, and is demanding that Norsigian and his consulting firm PRS Media Partners cease using Adams’s "name, likeness, and trademark" to sell prints and posters unauthorized by the organization. These include posters that Norsigian is selling on his Web site for $45 (which happens to be the same price he paid at a garage sale for all 65 negatives) and darkroom prints complete with certificates of authenticity for $7,500.

But the "authenticity" of the plates has become increasingly questionable in recent weeks, as even those working for Norsigian have ridiculed his original assertion that the find was worth $200 million. Counterclaims about the provenance of the works — given credence by the Trust in their suit, which was filed in a San Francisco court — emerged when a woman watching TV recognized the images as the work of her uncle, a little-known photographer named Earl Brooks who also worked in Yosemite and coastal California. The authenticators Norsigian relied on for the attribution of the negatives, furthermore, have been largely discredited — with one being outed as an ex-felon.

It remains to be seen whether the suit will influence plans of Beverly Hills gallerist David W. Streets to show Norsigian’s collection next month, but the stakes are certainly high. An Adams print, "Clearing Winter Storm, Yosemite National Park," was sold for $722,500 at auction this summer, setting a record for 20th-century photography.

"I'm sure Ansel never would've imagined a scam on this scale," the Adams Trust’s managing director Bill Turnage told the Associated Press. "I never thought it would come to this, but we have to try to do our duty to protect his work and reputation."

Source: Artinfo


More news

Can the art fair experience be replicated online? VIP Art Fair aims to try when in launches a special week-long art event January 22 through 30. They've got some big names in on the deal, founding galleries include Gagosian Gallery, David Zwirner, Hauser & Wirth and White Cube.
23 August '10


CAIRO — Egypt's top prosecutor says security lapses are to blame for the theft of a Vincent van Gogh painting from a Cairo museum.
23 August '10


A painting by Vincent van Gogh valued at £32 million has been stolen from a museum in Egypt.
21 August '10


MIAMI .- Thieves stole a $550,000 gold bar from a treasure museum where it went on display after a Florida salvager recovered it from the wreck of a Spanish galleon that lay on the ocean floor for centuries, the museum's executive director said.
21 August '10


BRUGES.- The sculpture "Woman with Drawers" by Salvador Dali, valued at 100,000 euros, was stolen from an exhibition hall in Bruges (NW Belgium), the Belgian press said today.
21 August '10


Pablo Picasso, you still got it! The Metropolitan Museum of Art said on Tuesday that its recent exhibition of works by that 20th-century titan of creativity was its seventh highest-attended show in the museum’s history.
18 August '10


A longstanding tug-of-war has resumed between the city of Florence and the Italian state over Michelangelo’s David, after a report by state-appointed lawyers was made public. The document argues that although the statue was commissioned by the Florentine Republic in 1501, Italy became the rightful title-holder after its unification in the 19th century.
16 August '10


WASHINGTON, DC.- Haunting images of love, attraction, alienation, death, and other universal human experiences in the work of Norwegian artist Edvard Munch (1865–1944) will be presented in a fascinating exhibition of nearly 60 of his most important prints. On view at the National Gallery of Art, Washington, from July 31 through October 31, 2010, Edvard Munch: Master Prints examines the artist’s stylistic approach to each of these themes, a process that involved transforming ideas into an evocative motif and exploring that image through numerous variations over a lifetime.
13 August '10


MEXICO CITY.- More than 1,600 years ago, nearly 8,000 shells and seeds gave form to a tapestry part of the funerary attire of a high rank personage of the ancient city of Calakmul. After its discovery in 1998 and hard work restoring and reconstructing it, the piece will be exhibited for the first time at the National Museum of Anthropology
13 August '10


JERUSALEM.- The coin, which apparently served ritual purposes, depicts a queen — apparently Arsinoë II — wife of her brother Ptolemy II
12 August '10


Developer to build imitation version of Cadaqués in Xiamen Bay, to the astonishment of residents of the Costa Brava port.
10 August '10


An "unprecedented" Leonardo da Vinci exhibition bringing together artworks never before seen in Britain will be staged next year by [The National Gallery](http://www.artlistings.com/museums/d/1850/the-national-gallery/london/) in London.
11 August '10


Rick Norsigian's 10-year quest to prove that he turned up a trove of "lost" Ansel Adams photo negatives at a Fresno garage sale now has a rival explanation advanced by Norsigian's opponents: They were taken by a heretofore unknown photographer from the Fresno area named Earl Brooks.
09 August '10


SAN FRANCISCO, CA.- From August 7, 2010, through January 16, 2011, the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art will showcase the exhibition Prints by Paul Klee (1946). Organized by John Zarobell, SFMOMA assistant curator, collections, exhibitions, and commissions, the exhibition features 21 works.
08 August '10


JERUSALEM.- An extraordinary and unique artifact discovered in an excavation fascinates archaeologists at the Israel Antiquities Authority: A Rare Bronze Horned-Bracelet, 3,500 Years Old.
06 August '10


LIVERPOOL.- Video artist, performer and composer Nam June Paik (1932-2006) was one of the most innovative artists of the 20th century and is widely considered to be the first video artist. From 17 December 2010 - 13 March 2011 Tate Liverpool, in collaboration with FACT (Foundation for Art and Creative Technology), presents the first major retrospective of Paik’s work in the UK. Displaying works from all phases of his career, many shown in the UK for the first time, the exhibition traces the artist’s avant-garde and experimental spirit.
06 August '10


CAIRO - After a seven-year facelift, the world's biggest museum of Islamic art will reopen in Cairo in the coming weeks, museum officials said on Wednesday.
05 August '10


LONDON. A panel from Dürer’s first major altarpiece has been restored after a 21-year treatment following a devastating acid attack in Munich. The Virgin of Sorrows has been unveiled in Dresden, where it was reunited with the rest of the altarpiece of the Seven Sorrows for the first time in nearly five centuries.
05 August '10


Featured dealer
Follow ArtListings
Search dealers
Fill in name


New on ArtListings
Art & Antiques Fairs
Museum exhibitions
Videos
Follow ArtListings