Curator Cancels Ansel Adams Authentication Claim

01 September '10 by the editors

SAN FRANCISCO – Though entrepreneur Rick Norsigian continues to argue that photographic negatives he purchased at a California garage sale are the work of famed American photographer Ansel Adams, the evidence supporting that stance is quickly unraveling. One of the experts that had authenticated the works, former Museum of Fine Arts, Boston curator Robert C. Moeller III, has recanted his previous assessment, telling the New York Times that at least some of the photographs were taken by another man, Earl Brooks. Norsigian has been working with a team of lawyers to sell prints of the negatives, which he says are worth $200 million.

"Maybe I kind of wanted them to be Ansel Adams," Moeller told the Times, saying that he changed his mind after viewing a series of prints owned by Brooks’s niece, given to her by her late uncle, that matched pictures that Norsigian says are by Adams. "It didn’t take me long to say they were same camera, same time, same man," Moeller admitted. "My report, which said there was a high probability that Ansel Adams took the photos, has got to change." Still, Moeller is alone in his change of heart: the Times notes that no other experts have yet withdrawn their authentication claim, despite the new evidence.

A lawyer for Norsigian disputed Moeller’s new stance, saying that, since Brooks’s niece does not possess the original negatives, there is no evidence that her uncle actually photographed the scenes of mountains and forests that have been attributed to Adams. The lawyer also pointed to the fact that a meteorologist hired by a group marketing the photos has stated that the weather patterns visible in the park match those seen in other works definitively made by Adams.

Moeller’s switch is not the only new problem that Norsigian and his team have to contend with. The Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust has also filed a suit in federal court alleging that Norsigian’s business infringes trademarks that it owns.


Comment


More news

MEXICO CITY - Carlos Slim, the world's richest man, will soon open a new museum in one of the poshest areas of his native Mexico to house his collection of artwork by French sculptor Auguste Rodin, considered the biggest outside France.
01 September '10


VENICE - A painting by Renaissance master Titian in one of Venice's most picturesque basilicas has suffered water damage after firefighters doused the basilica while battling a nearby blaze.
30 August '10


The pair who sold fake prints claiming they were by the graffiti artist have also been banned from selling anything on the internet for five years.
26 August '10


When Lehman Brothers' collection of "artwork and ephemera" goes under the hammer at Christie's in South Kensington next month, the general public will be given an intriguing insight into the world of corporate art collecting.
27 August '10


LONDON – Corporations worried about the bottom line are taking a look at their office walls.
26 August '10


CAIRO – Egyptian billionaire Naguib Sawiris has offered a 1-million Egyptian pound ($175,300) reward for information leading to the recovery of a stolen Van Gogh painting, television reported on Wednesday.
27 August '10


CAIRO – On Saturday, Vincent van Gogh’s 1887 still life "Poppy Flowers," valued at more than $50 million, was stolen from the Mahmoud Khalil Museum in Cairo. The past three days have seen news of arrests, a false report that the painting had been recovered, and general chaos within Egypt's cultural ranks. Here are the latest updates.
24 August '10


SAN FRANCISCO – The controversy over Rick Norsigian's trove of alleged Ansel Adams negatives has reached a fever pitch, with the Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust filing a lawsuit to stop the sale of merchandise made from the glass plates — and asserting in the process that the Fresno artist is, in fact, a scam artist.
25 August '10


Can the art fair experience be replicated online? VIP Art Fair aims to try when in launches a special week-long art event January 22 through 30. They've got some big names in on the deal, founding galleries include Gagosian Gallery, David Zwirner, Hauser & Wirth and White Cube.
23 August '10


CAIRO — Egypt's top prosecutor says security lapses are to blame for the theft of a Vincent van Gogh painting from a Cairo museum.
23 August '10


A painting by Vincent van Gogh valued at £32 million has been stolen from a museum in Egypt.
21 August '10


MIAMI .- Thieves stole a $550,000 gold bar from a treasure museum where it went on display after a Florida salvager recovered it from the wreck of a Spanish galleon that lay on the ocean floor for centuries, the museum's executive director said.
21 August '10


BRUGES.- The sculpture "Woman with Drawers" by Salvador Dali, valued at 100,000 euros, was stolen from an exhibition hall in Bruges (NW Belgium), the Belgian press said today.
21 August '10


Pablo Picasso, you still got it! The Metropolitan Museum of Art said on Tuesday that its recent exhibition of works by that 20th-century titan of creativity was its seventh highest-attended show in the museum’s history.
18 August '10


A longstanding tug-of-war has resumed between the city of Florence and the Italian state over Michelangelo’s David, after a report by state-appointed lawyers was made public. The document argues that although the statue was commissioned by the Florentine Republic in 1501, Italy became the rightful title-holder after its unification in the 19th century.
16 August '10


WASHINGTON, DC.- Haunting images of love, attraction, alienation, death, and other universal human experiences in the work of Norwegian artist Edvard Munch (1865–1944) will be presented in a fascinating exhibition of nearly 60 of his most important prints. On view at the National Gallery of Art, Washington, from July 31 through October 31, 2010, Edvard Munch: Master Prints examines the artist’s stylistic approach to each of these themes, a process that involved transforming ideas into an evocative motif and exploring that image through numerous variations over a lifetime.
13 August '10


MEXICO CITY.- More than 1,600 years ago, nearly 8,000 shells and seeds gave form to a tapestry part of the funerary attire of a high rank personage of the ancient city of Calakmul. After its discovery in 1998 and hard work restoring and reconstructing it, the piece will be exhibited for the first time at the National Museum of Anthropology
13 August '10


JERUSALEM.- The coin, which apparently served ritual purposes, depicts a queen — apparently Arsinoë II — wife of her brother Ptolemy II
12 August '10


Featured dealer
Follow ArtListings
Search dealers
Fill in name


New on ArtListings
Art & Antiques Fairs
Museum exhibitions
Videos
Follow ArtListings